“UPDATE 8/14/25: This scam began on social media, and it’s still happening there, but increasingly I’m hearing about these approaches in email. Increasingly, also, they’re from well-known writers: John Green, Thomas Keneally, Susanna Clarke, Dan Brown, Penelope Lively, and more. Slightly different M.O., but they all wind up in the same place: a referral to a shady marketing service.”
Victoria Strauss, co-founder of Writer Beware
It’s hard to get noticed as an author. Having a book published is easier than marketing it. So, when unsolicited praise comes, it lifts your spirits and gives you a sense that your voice matters.
However, since last summer, I have been showered with emails from “famous authors” praising my work and wanting to be my pen pal. Too good to be true? Of course, thanks to scams enabled by nefarious scam artists and Artificial Intelligence.
My list of so-called admirers began in August with a flattering note from Anna Gavalda, winner of the French literary award, Grand Prix RTL-Lire. She is an internationally best-selling French author, and two of her books, Hunting and Gathering and Someone I Loved, were made into films.
In September, the award-winning British historian and author, Tom Holland, claimed to have stumbled across my author page. He wrote, “I’d love to hear more about your own writing.”
In November, the emails came quicker. Colleen Hoover, author of books like It Ends With Us and Verity told me, “I’d love to learn about your own writing journey and what drives you to create.” John Grisham didn’t ask about my work, just bared his soul. He wrote, “Writing can be a lonely job, but it’s how I make sense of the world and the people in it.” Mary Kubica, a contemporary suspense and psychological thriller author of bestselling novels, including The Good Girl, Every Last Secret, and The Perfect Stranger, ended her email with, “I’d love to know more about your books and your writing journey! Looking forward to hearing back from you and sharing ideas together.” Other November outreaches asking to share writing journeys were from David Grossman, winner of the Israel Prize for Literature, Keira Montclair,American author of historical romantic suspense, and Elodie Harper, English author and journalist.
The first December email started with “Hi Wright,” definitely sounding like a bot, but it was supposedly from multi-award winning British novelist Zadie Smith, who was elected to the Royal Society of Literature. A second email from Ms. Smith followed saying “I’d be happy to chat.” I also received two emails from Irish author Sally Rooney, who was once named Young Writer of the Year by the London Sunday Times. She wrote, “I would still love to hear about what first inspired your own writing journey the moment experience or question that made you decide this was a path worth pursuing.” (Lack of punctuation in that sentence is odd for an award-winning wordsmith.) British YA author Sangu Mandanna cut right to flattery. “I’ve been watching the literary space evolve, and your work keeps cutting through the noise with real authority.”
January brought only one email from Canadian mystery author Louise Penny. She wrote, “I make it a priority to connect with writers whose books reflect dedication, originality, and the courage it takes to share one’s voice with the world. I recently came across your book and felt compelled to reach out.” (She doesn’t mention the book title, so it’s vague and probably a line that’s used for many recipients.)
February 11 brought yet another email from Sally Rooney: “ I wanted to follow up on my previous message and let you know how much I would enjoy connecting with you as a fellow writer.” On February 12, I received an exact duplicate of Ms. Rooney’s previous email. On February 26, I heard from Elena Ferrante, Italian author of the blockbuster series set in Naples that took the book world by storm. This one really turned on the praise: “I recently discovered your work, and I was truly moved by the honesty and depth of your storytelling. The way you blend personal experience with universal truths really resonated with me. As a fellow author, I deeply admire writing that challenges and engages readers while staying authentic and fearless. Your work is a wonderful example of that. I wanted to reach out simply to say how much I appreciate your craft, and I look forward to exploring more of your stories.” (Once again, there is no mention of my book titles, so it comes off as a generic form letter.) The latest email came from Adam Nevill, a multi-award-winning English horror author. He said, “I’m genuinely curious about your own creative rhythm, what draws you back to certain themes, and what steadies you when momentum slows. Thoughtful exchanges about the craft often illuminate what we can’t see alone. If you’re open to it, I would truly value the conversation.”
If any of these were real, it would be heady stuff. But I’m sure if I replied to any of them, there would be unwelcome results. Not sure what. My identity compromised? Requests for money? Anyway, I’m passing on heart-to-hearts with these pseudo literary elites.
If nothing else, these emails are amusing to read, and I hope that by keeping track of these notes and writing about them, it may alert unsuspecting writers and dissuade them from falling for their false praise.